First-team selections only

1981-82
Large schools
G - Kevin Moore, sr., Newburgh Free-1
G - Alex Agudio, sr. Walt Whitman-11
F - Endy Basquiat, sr., Spring Valley-9
F - Tom Sheehey, jr., Rochester McQuaid-5
C - Tim Kempton, sr., St. Dominic's-8
Small schools
G - Dave Roberson, sr., Tuckahoe-1
G - Kevin Read, sr., Miller Place-11
F - Kevin Lewis, sr., Highland Falls O'Neill-9
F - Maurice Martin, sr., Liberty-9
C - Bruce Lefkowitz, jr., Edgemont-1

1982-83
Large schools
G - Curtis Aiken, sr., Buffalo Bennett-6
F - Tom Sheehey, sr., Rochester McQuaid-5
F - Russell Pierre, sr., North Babylon-11
F - Terry Williams, sr., Newburgh Free-1
C - Augusto Binelli, sr., Lutheran-8
Small schools
G - Mike Cinque, sr., Goshen Burke-9
G - Dinky Miller, sr., East Hampton-11
F - Matt Ryan, jr., Miller Place-11
F - Brian Fitzpatrick, sr., Irvington-1
C - Bruce Lefkowitz, sr., Edgemont-1

1983-84
Large schools
G - John Johnson, sr., Tolentine-NYC
G - Rodney Strickland, jr., Truman-NYC
F - Shelton Jones, sr., Amityville-11
F - Derrick Chievous, sr., Holy Cross-NYC
C - Steve Wright, sr., Syracuse Fowler-3
Small schools
G - Rod Harris, sr., Bridgehampton-11
G - Chris Avignon, sr., St. Hugh's-NYC
F - Matt Ryan, sr., Miller Place-11
F - Victor Brown, sr., Berkeley School-NYC
C - Tyrone Scott, sr., Geneva-5

1984-85
Large schools
G - Greg Harvey, sr., Jackson-NYC
G - Gerald Greene, sr. Westinghouse-NYC
F - John Morton, sr., Walton-NYC
F - Gary Massey, sr., St. Raymond-NYC
C - Darryl Walker, sr., All Hollows-NYC
Small schools
G - John Ward, sr., Center Moriches-11
G - Kevin Broderick, sr., Oswego Bishop Cunningham-3
F - Brent Bass, jr., Alexander Hamilton-1
F - Derald Preston, sr., Friends Academy-8
C - Juliam Johnson, jr., Bridgehampton-11

1985-86
Large schools
G - King Rice, jr., Binghamton-4
G - Eric Leslie, sr., Grady-NYC
F - Lloyd Daniels, sr., Jackson-NYC
F - Keith Robinson, sr., Buffalo Grover Cleveland-6 
C - Tom Greis, sr., St. Anthony-11
Small schools
G - Troy Bowe, jr., Bridgehamton-11
G - Terry Brown, sr., Slyde-Savannah-5
G/F - George Robinson, sr., Manhasset-8
F - Steve Watson, sr., Olean Walsh-6
C - Duane Ivory, sr., Our Saviour Lutheran-NYC

1986-87
Large schools
G - King Rice, sr., Binghamton-4
G - Ken Anderson, soph., Archbishop Molloy-NYC
F - Ralph James, sr., Archbishop Molloy-NYC
F - Greg Koubek, sr., Shenendehowa-2
C - Bill Singleton, sr., Stevenson-NYC
Small schools
G - Troy Bowe, sr., Bridgehampton-11
G - Arnold Bernard, sr., Our Saviour Lutheran-NYC
F - Ural Hogan, sr., Alexander Hamilton-1
F - Bob Gordon, sr., Manhasset-8
C - Jonathan Duck, sr. Our Saviour Lutheran-NYC

1987-88
Large schools
G - Ken Anderson, jr., Archbishop Molloy-NYC
G/F - Greg Woodard, sr., McQuaid-5
F - Malik Sealy, sr., Tolentine-NYC
F - Robert Werdann, sr., Archbishop Molloy-NYC
C - Christian Laettner, sr., Buffalo Nichols-6
Small schools
G - Danny Tirado, sr., Our Saviour Lutheran-NYC
G - Jim Ryder, sr., Tioga-4
F - Scott Nesbitt, sr., Sugarloaf-9
F - Ellis Christmas, sr., Alexander Hamilton-1
C - Jon Mueller, sr., Stillwater-2