2001
Class A - Julius Hodge, St. Raymond-NYC
Class B - Tristan Smith, Amityville-11
Class C - Daryl Jacobs, Buff. Traditional-6, and Terry George, Buff. Traditional-6
Class D - Jeff Weaver, Batavia Notre Dame-5

2002
Class A - Chris Turner, Syr. Henninger-3, and Curtis Sumpter, Bishop Loughlin-NYC
Class B - Jason Fraser, Amityville-11
Class C - Jason Stein, Blind Brook-1
Class D - Ryan Nellenback, Faith Heritage-3

2003
Class A - Sebastian Telfair, Abraham Lincoln-NYC
Class B - A.J. Price, Amityville-11
Class C - Micole Parker, Buffalo City Honors-6
Class D - Michael Hoyt, Seward-9

2004
Class AA -- Sebastian Telfair, Abraham Lincoln-NYC
Class A -- A.J. Price, Amityville-11, and Jeremy Black, Jamesville-DeWitt-3
Class B - Peter Courtney, Somers JFK-1
Class C - Tom Wethington, Blind Brook-1
Class D - Mike McDuffie, Alexander Hamilton-1

2005
Class AA - Paul Harris, Niagara Falls-6
Class A - Kyle McAlarney, Moore Catholic-NYC
Class B - Ray Blackburn, Lackawanna-6
Class C - Robert McDowell, Sodus-5
Class D - Cameron Maziejka, Fort Edward-2

2006
Class AA - Jonathan Mitchell, Mount Vernon-1
Class A - Tyrone Nash, Lawrence-Woodmere-AIS
Class B - Lesean Braxton, Lackawanna-6
Class C - Matt Newman, Campbell-Savona-5, and Will Cornett, Campbell-Savona-5
Class D - Andy Marchand, C.G. Finney-5

2007
Class AA - Michael Coburn, Mount Vernon-1, and Jonny Flynn, Niagara Falls-6
Class A - Mookie Jones, Peekskill-1
Class B - Craig Wilson, Malverne-8, and Greg Lott, Malverne-8
Class C - Andy Foote, Sidney-4
Class D - Andy Marchand, C.G. Finney-5
 
2008
Class AA - Sylven Landesberg, Holy Cross-CHSAA
Class A - Brandon Triche, Jamesville-DeWitt-3
Class B - Mike Nelson, Collegiate-AIS
Class C - Chris Secky, Maple Grove-6
Class D - Ryan Creighton, Greenport-11

2009
Class AA - Lance Stephenson, Abraham Lincoln-PSAL
Class A - Brandon Triche, Jamesville-DeWitt-3, and Tobias Harris, LI Lutheran-AIS
Class B - Will Bartlett, Collegiate-AIS
Class C - Dan Banach, Avon-5
Class D - Chris Secky, Maple Grove-6, and Ryan Creighton, Greenport-11

2010
Class AA - Tobias Harris, Half Hollow Hills West-11
Class A - Will Regan, Buffalo Nichols-CHSAA
Class B - Will Bartlett, Collegiate-AIS
Class C - Darale Young, Buffalo OTC Middle College-6
Class D - Chris Secky, Maple Grove-6

2011
Class AA - Jabarie Hinds, Mount Vernon-1
Class A - Achraf Yacoubou, Long Island Lutheran-AIS
Class B - Kevin Punter, Salesian-CHSAA
Class C - Chris Holland, I-Prep at Grover Cleveland-6
Class D - Fred Russ, New York Mills-3